zionsville jewelry store midwest jewelers and estate buyers address and phone number
Mon-Wed: 9am-5pm
Thursday: 9am-6pm
Friday: 9am-4.30pm
Saturday: 10am-3pm
Sunday: closed

Sell Your Valuables

Ask us any questions you have about a jewelry piece you want to sell!

Visit Our eBay Store for Antiques & Collectibles

antique and collectible store in Zionsville, Indiana - Hidden Treasures Antiques

Sell Your Diamonds and Diamond Jewelry in the Indianapolis area:

Looking to sell your diamond or diamond jewelry for cash? We offer safe and secure diamond buying services while offering you top dollar paid! Our professional gemologists are experts in grading and evaluating your diamonds to help get you the best possible price. We buy diamonds in all shapes and carat weights, loose or in jewelry! With over 50 years of combined experience and an A+ Better Business Bureau rating, we have the training and experience to properly evaluate the four c’s of diamonds : color, clarity, carat weight and cut of your diamond, all of which can have an impact on the value. We offer FREE verbal appraisals, simply call to setup an appointment or stop by our store.

Our comfortable and confidential offices offer a private setting where you can conduct the sale of your diamond in privacy.


Indianapolis Diamond Buyer:

You can also trade your valuables towards a new purchase!

Do you have jewelry or watches that you just don’t wear anymore? Trade in your fine or estate jewelry, diamond jewelry, watch or scrap gold towards anything else in the store. Your valuables may be worth more than you think!

Sell Your Diamond Jewelry For Cash Today!

Visit our jewelry store in Zionsville, Indiana during regular business hours to have your diamond jewelry looked at by an expert. You can also contact us to schedule a jewelry appraisal appointment.

ask a jewelry expert a selling question or schedule appointment

Types of Diamonds You Can Sell:
We value each and every diamond on an individual basis, taking into consideration the diamond’s history, brand name, cut, clarity, carat weight and potential. Below are just a few of the types of diamonds that we appraise and purchase every day.

  • Large Carat Diamonds
  • Antique Diamonds
  • Estate Diamonds
  • Diamond Engagement Rings
  • Diamond Stud Earrings
  • Diamond Necklaces
  • Diamond Bracelets
  • Diamond Rings
  • Diamond Solitaire Pendants
  • and More!


Midwest Jewelers & Estate Buyers pays the best price for your diamond in Indianapolis —any size, any shape, any grade—whether loose or in a setting. We personally evaluate all diamonds and jewelry and every customer is treated with fairness and respect.

Why Choose Us As Your Trusted Diamond Jewelry Buyer in the Indianapolis area


All transactions are confidential and secure. We understand that selling your valuables can be an emotional experience so we don’t pressure you while you make your decision.


Our buying offices are safe, secure, and private, with professional graduate gemologists on hand to assist you. Don’t hesitate to contact us before you drop by!


Click Here to ask one of our jewelry experts a question, call us at 317-733-0099 or visit us at our Zionsville, IN jewelry store with any questions you have about any diamond jewelry you want to sell.

We Pay More!

Bottom line – We can pay more for your diamonds!

Tips for Selling your Diamond Jewelry

Understand what you got

Get an accurate idea as to the true quality and authenticity of the stone in question. You can get an unbiased opinion about the stone’s condition and characteristics by consulting with a qualified appraiser. Take advantage our FREE verbal appraisals next time your in our store.

Set a realistic price

Having unrealistic price expectations for your diamond is the fastest way to disappointment with any ultimate sale. Ask how much the stone might be worth in specific markets and circumstances as these factors among others determine the value of your diamonds.

Put your emotions aside

More than any other precious stones, diamonds are associated with love and hence, are harder to part with. This is why you should make sure that you are actually prepared to sell your diamond ring before going through with this. Don’t sell your diamonds if you have the slightest regret about selling your diamond jewelry, its best to be very sure your ready to part ways with your piece.

Additional Resources to Help Sell Your Diamonds & Diamond Jewelry:


Connect With Us!

get updates on the latest jewelry pieces, gift ideas, exclusive giveaways & more!

Ask a Question About Selling Your Jewelry or Gold

5 + 8 =

Address: 190 South Main Street Zionsville, IN 46077

Tel: 866-733-0099 or


The Coolest Place in Indiana, to Buy & Sell Jewelry!